Rembrandt van Rijn · 1660

A young man with long hair and a light beard folds his arms and looks straight at us. For two centuries this Christ was a celebrated Rembrandt. Then photographs of a restoration revealed that its centre had been cut out and replaced.
The painting has been known since the early 18th century. In the early 19th century it belonged to Cardinal Joseph Fesch, a half uncle of Napoleon, whose collection reportedly held more than 20,000 paintings. It was auctioned in Rome in 1845, then passed through Paris collections, including the dealer Charles Sedelmeyer from 1873, and on to Count Orloff-Davidoff in Saint Petersburg. After the October Revolution it went to the Soviet state, was in the Pushkin Museum in 1927, and in 1933 was sold abroad to the American paper industrialist Louis Hyde.
The life-size half figure of a young man stands with arms crossed before his chest, the left over the right. He is seen from half left and meets our eyes with his head slightly tilted. His dark brown hair, parted in the middle, falls in waves past his shoulders, and he has a light full beard. He wears a dull red garment with a dark cloak over his left shoulder. Light from above falls on his face, while the chest and hand emerge from a dark, shapeless background. It is neither signed nor dated.
Scholars long read it as a high point of Rembrandt's late work. In 1956 Otto Benesch called it the most monumental painting of its kind, and Wilhelm Reinhold Valentiner saw it as the central figure of a series of evangelist portraits. Seymour Slive linked it to a group of small heads of Christ, all thought to use the same young man as model, and imagined Rembrandt enlarging one into a new vision of Christ. Horst Gerson still called it a beautiful interpretation of the ideal image of Christ in 1969.
In 1988 Gary Schwartz published photographs of a 1958 restoration. They showed that the central part of the canvas had at some point been cut out and replaced, so much of the picture is a restorer's work, and the surface is in poor condition. Major Rembrandt catalogues no longer list it. German Wikipedia now describes it as by an unknown Dutch painter, around 1659, while Wikidata still gives Rembrandt and 1660, and its owner, The Hyde Collection in Glens Falls, New York, still presents it as an original Rembrandt.
Rembrandt van Rijn (1606-1669)
夜警 - Rembrandt van Rijn (1642)
自画像 - Rembrandt van Rijn (1659)
テュルプ博士の解剖学講義 - Rembrandt van Rijn (1632)
ユダヤの花嫁 - Rembrandt van Rijn (1660s)
ガラリアの海の嵐 - Rembrandt van Rijn (1633)
放蕩息子の帰還 - Rembrandt van Rijn (1668)
ダナエ - Rembrandt van Rijn (1636)
ベルシャザルの酒宴 - Rembrandt van Rijn (1636)
真珠の耳飾りの少女 - Johannes Vermeer (1665)
牛乳を注ぐ女 - Johannes Vermeer (c. 1658)
聖ニコラウスのお祭り - Jan Steen (1660s)
牡蠣を食べる少女 - Jan Steen (1658)
陽気な酒飲み - Frans Hals (1620s)
微笑む騎士 - Frans Hals (1624)
ウェイク・ベイ・ドゥールステーデの風車 - Jacob van Ruisdael (1670)
The Jewish Cemetery - Jacob van Ruisdael (1650s)
デルフトの家の中庭 - Pieter de Hooch (1658)
リンゴの皮を剥く女性 - Pieter de Hooch (1663)