El Greco · 1600s
.jpg)
An unfinished gentleman, his hands hidden in his cuffs, his clothes only sketched in, but his face unmistakably El Greco's. Scholars still disagree whether the master painted it himself.
This portrait of a hidalgo, or gentleman, is dated to around 1607 and attributed to El Greco. It is oil on canvas, 108 by 86 cm, and appears as number X-175 in the catalogue raisonné by Harold Wethey, the historian who specialised in the artist. The painting is unfinished and in poor condition. It has been cleaned too harshly, and little of the original paint remains. Wikidata simply places it in the 1600s, so the date of about 1607 comes from the Spanish Wikipedia.
The gentleman is shown at more than half length. His hands are not visible, hidden by his cuffs, and his costume is only summarily painted. The face, however, is typical of El Greco, both in its type and in the way it is painted. Look at that face first: it is the part where the hand of the painter is clearest. The contrast between the careful head and the sketched clothing is part of what makes an unfinished canvas so revealing.
The question of authorship divides the experts. Mayer, Gudiol and Camón Aznar consider it an authentic work. Gudiol saw in it a skill that even El Greco's best collaborators would not have reached. Wethey, on the other hand, classed it as a work of the workshop or school of El Greco. The painting therefore hangs between two judgments, and its damaged surface makes the question harder to settle, perhaps for good.
Its history before the Minneapolis collector Herschel V. Jones bought it was reconstructed by Professor Ellis Waterhouse. It passed from Miguel Borondo in Madrid through L. Harris in London, Kleinberger in Paris, Julius Böhler in Munich, a dealer in Lucerne and Reinhart in New York. Jones owned it until 1934, and the Minneapolis Institute of Art held it from 1934 to 1957. It then went to Julius Weitzner in New York and later to a private collection in Milan.
El Greco (1541-1614)
View of Toledo - El Greco (1596)
The Disrobing of Christ - El Greco (1570s)
Opening of the Fifth Seal - El Greco (1610)
The Nobleman with his Hand on his Chest - El Greco (1580)
Laocoön - El Greco (1610s)
Saint Martin and the Beggar - El Greco (1597)
Adoration of the Shepherds - El Greco (1612)
The Wedding at Cana - Paolo Veronese (1560s)
The Feast in the House of Levi - Paolo Veronese (1573)
Last Supper - Jacopo Tintoretto (1563)
Miracle of the Slave - Jacopo Tintoretto (1540s)
Venus of Urbino - Titian (1538)
Assumption of the Virgin - Titian (1510s)
Supper at Emmaus - Caravaggio (1601)
La vocazione di San Matteo - Caravaggio (1609)
The Ambassadors - Hans Holbein the Younger (1533)
The Body of the Dead Christ in the Tomb - Hans Holbein the Younger (1520s)