El Misántropo

Pieter Bruegel the Elder · 1568

El Misántropo - Pieter Bruegel the Elder

An old man in black walks away from the world, hands clasped, eyes lowered, while a ragged little thief inside a glass globe cuts his purse and spiked caltrops wait on his path. Bruegel painted this bitter round picture in 1568.

The story behind the painting

The Misanthrope is a tempera painting on canvas made by Pieter Bruegel the Elder in 1568, a small moral picture whose symbols invite more than one reading. The circular scene is set inside a square frame, and at the bottom runs a Flemish inscription: Because the world is perfidious, I am going into mourning. The picture is a moral image built around that line, with every figure answering the old man's complaint. It measures about 86 by 85 cm and is now in the National Museum of Capodimonte in Naples. The sources do not say who commissioned it or where it hung before reaching Naples.

What to look for

A white-bearded old man in a black hooded robe clasps his hands before him. Behind him, a smaller barefoot man uses a knife to cut the strings of his money pouch. The old man seems so lost in thought that he notices neither the theft nor the caltrops, the spiked metal traps scattered in his path. The thief is enclosed in a globe topped with a cross, a globus cruciger. In the background, far from this little drama, a shepherd watches over his sheep. Read the round picture slowly, from the inscription up to the figures and out to the landscape.

Meaning and intent

The figure in the globe may stand for vanity, though the religious symbolism of the globe opens other readings: the world itself is robbing the man who claims to leave it. The caltrops set in his path show that he cannot simply walk away from the world as he wishes. Bruegel contrasts him with the shepherd in the background, who is presented as more virtuous because he simply and honourably does his duty and takes responsibility for those in his care. Withdrawal, the picture seems to say, is not the same as goodness, and complaining about the world does not protect you from it.

Legacy

Bruegel's son Pieter Bruegel the Younger was known for making many copies of his father's works, and he painted his own Misanthrope, also tempera on canvas, with a slightly different composition. That version entered the permanent collection of the Bank of the Republic of Colombia in 1999, and since August 2023 it has been shown at the Museo Casa de Moneda in Bogotá. So the old man in black, still being robbed and still not noticing, can be met today on two continents: in Naples, in his father's original, and in Bogotá, in the son's variation.

¿Sabías que…?

Wikipedia · Wikidata

Sobre el artista

Pieter Bruegel the Elder (1525-1569)

varón · escena de género · Museo Nacional de Capodimonte · Orbe

Más obras de Pieter Bruegel the Elder

Obras de artistas relacionados