Winslow Homer · 1876

Two young Black women stand in a cotton field that runs to the horizon, their basket and sack nearly full. They picked cotton before the war and they are still picking it after. Homer painted them in 1876, as Reconstruction was ending.
Homer began as a lithographer's apprentice and Civil War artist-correspondent for Harper's Weekly. After the war he returned to Petersburg, Virginia, where he had spent time during the final siege, and from 1874 to 1876 he made studies of rural African American life. The source calls him the first American to paint African Americans consistently without condescension or sentimentality. In 1876 Federal troops were withdrawing from the South, and the hopes of the post-war years were giving way to racism and the coming Jim Crow laws.
The palette is browns and silvery greys on a canvas about 24 by 38 inches. Seen from a low viewpoint, the women fill the canvas in cotton blouses and long skirts. Neither is picking: the one on the left, holding a bushel basket, stoops to brush a plant with her hand, while the one on the right, a sack across her shoulder, stands upright gazing into the distance. The light suggests early morning. The cotton hides their legs, and the darkly painted figures stand against a pale background, with a low blue-green mountain range, a forest on the left and a single tall pine on the right.
Writers have read the hidden legs as an illusion of being unable to move or escape, and the endless field as work that will never be finished. Yet the women look forward with thought and determination, and the horizon, moving from one tree to a forest, has been read as one hope becoming a united force for change. One historian argues Homer painted them as mixed race, which in his time was wrongly thought to limit their future. Another sees a gap between realistic detail and mysterious expressions, making inner consciousness itself the subject.
Compared with the caricatures of the time, Homer's heroic workers recall Millet and Jules Breton, and the painting has been called his most monumental figure painting. It was first shown in 1877 at the Century Club, where Homer was a member, and was bought by a wealthy cotton spinner who took it to England, so for years it was little known in America. From 1911 to 1944 it belonged to Dr. Charles B. Guinn of Carthage, Missouri. It is now at the Los Angeles County Museum of Art.
Winslow Homer (1836-1910)
genre art · double portrait · Los Angeles County Museum of Art
Breezing Up - Winslow Homer (1873)
The Fog Warning - Winslow Homer (1885)
The Gulf Stream - Winslow Homer (1899)
Fox Hunt - Winslow Homer (1893)
A Visit from the Old Mistress - Winslow Homer (1876)
Eight Bells - Winslow Homer (1886)
In Front of Yorktown - Winslow Homer (1860s)
Right and Left - Winslow Homer (1909)
L'Origine du monde - Gustave Courbet (1866)
A Burial at Ornans - Gustave Courbet (2020)
Luncheon on the Grass - Édouard Manet (1863)
Olympia - Édouard Manet (1863)
The Starry Night - Vincent van Gogh (1889)
Café Terrace at Night - Vincent van Gogh (1888)