Frans Hals · 1626

A young lute player looks straight at us and tips his glass upside down: empty, time is up. For centuries the painting was given to Frans Hals, but some scholars now see the hand of Judith Leyster.
The painting is known as The Fingernail Test and also as Boy with a Glass and a Lute. It is dated 1626. It was attributed to Frans Hals for centuries, until the scholar Claus Grimm called it a product of his circle. According to Hofrichter, the figure sitting behind a table is a typical theme of Judith Leyster, the upward glance recalls her Violin Player, and the handling of paint is close to her Two Children with a Cat. So the picture is now attributed to either Hals or Leyster, and the question remains open.
In his 1910 catalogue Hofstede de Groot described a half-length mandoline player seated at a table, his body turned three-quarters right but facing the viewer. In his raised right hand, little finger lifted, he holds a green goblet upside down, his left hand beneath it, also with the little finger raised. The top of the orange-yellow instrument rests on his left arm. He has long hair and a cap on the back of his head, a bright red costume with a greyish-purple cloak, white frills at the wrists and a white band at the throat, against an olive-green curtain.
In the 17th century, tipping a glass over to see whether a drop of wine fell on a fingernail was a way of showing that one wanted a refill. Scenes of this gesture often show figures in theatrical costume, like this boy in his beret and draped cloak. Facing us, he shows the glass is empty, as if to say that time is up. The painting may be related to Young Man with a Skull, where a boy also wears a beret and draped cloak.
Hofstede de Groot noted that the picture may be the one sold in Rotterdam in 1825. It was shown in Dublin in 1857 while in the collection of J. Napper of Lough Crew Castle, sold in Dublin in 1906, and then passed through the London dealers Dowdeswell and C. Wertheimer and the Paris dealers Kleinberger and Wildenstein, before entering the collection of B. Altman in New York. It is now in the Metropolitan Museum of Art. Wikidata gives its size as 72.1 by 59.1 cm.
Frans Hals (1591-1666)
genre art · boy · Metropolitan Museum of Art · portrait · lute · wine glass
A Militiaman Holding a Berkemeyer, Known as the ‘Merry Drinker’ - Frans Hals (1620s)
Laughing Cavalier - Frans Hals (1624)
Gipsy Girl - Frans Hals (1628)
Malle Babbe - Frans Hals (1640s)
Willem van Heythuysen posing with a sword - Frans Hals (1625)
Militia Company of District XI under the Command of Captain Reynier Reael - Frans Hals (1630s)
Jester with lute - Frans Hals (1623)
Merrymakers at Shrovetide - Frans Hals (1610s)
The Night Watch - Rembrandt van Rijn (1642)
Self-Portrait - Rembrandt van Rijn (1659)
Girl with a Pearl Earring - Johannes Vermeer (1665)
The Milkmaid - Johannes Vermeer (c. 1658)
The Feast of Saint Nicholas - Jan Steen (1660s)
Girl eating oysters - Jan Steen (1658)
The Windmill at Wijk bij Duurstede - Jacob van Ruisdael (1670)
The Jewish Cemetery - Jacob van Ruisdael (1650s)
The Courtyard of a House in Delft - Pieter de Hooch (1658)
A Woman Peeling Apples - Pieter de Hooch (1663)