Caravaggio · 1598

A youth sits on a red cloak among green vines and thorny stems, gazing down at a lamb at his feet. Whether Caravaggio painted this Toledo Baptist is still an open question, and that mystery is part of its pull.
This Saint John the Baptist, also called Saint John in the Wilderness, is dated around 1598 and kept in the Museo Tesoro Catedralicio, the cathedral treasury museum of Toledo. It has been attributed to Caravaggio, who made about seven versions of the theme, but research increasingly favours his contemporary Bartolomeo Cavarozzi. John Gash suggested in 2004 that it might be one of the paintings Caravaggio made for the prior of the Hospital of the Consolation, who, according to the early biographer Mancini, took them back to his homeland. One copy of Mancini's manuscript says Seville, another says Sicily.
John sits before a green vine mixed with thorny brambles, on a red cloak, holding a thin reed cross and looking at a lamb lying at his feet. The leaves behind him, and the plants and soil at his feet, are painted with careful, almost photographic detail, like the still life Basket of Fruit. The scholar Alfonso Pérez Sánchez found the vine leaves of extraordinary quality, more typical of Caravaggio than of Cavarozzi. Gash also points to the gentle chiaroscuro and delicate contours. The red cloak would become typical of Caravaggio's work.
The details carry meaning. The vine leaves recall the vine that gave the wine of the Last Supper, the thorns evoke the Crown of Thorns, and the lamb is a reminder of Christ's sacrifice. Showing John as a youth was somewhat unusual; he was more often an infant with the young Jesus, or an adult baptising him. Leonardo and Andrea del Sarto had already painted young Baptists with a private, hard to read meaning, and Caravaggio turned that approach into a personal icon across his many variations.
Peter Robb, who believes the painting is Caravaggio's, dates it to about 1598, when the artist lived with his first patron, Cardinal Francesco Maria del Monte, and sees in John the same model as in the Sacrifice of Isaac, itself a disputed work. The case for Cavarozzi remains strong, since he is known to have travelled to Spain around 1617 to 1619. If the painting was by Caravaggio and reached Seville early, it could have influenced the young Velázquez. Either way, it stays in Toledo, a quiet riddle.
Caravaggio (1571-1610)
エマオの晩餐 - Caravaggio (1601)
聖マタイの召命 - Caravaggio (1609)
洗礼者聖ヨハネの斬首 - Caravaggio (1608)
エマオの晩餐 - Caravaggio (1601)
メドゥーサの首 - Caravaggio (1597)
ホロフェルネスの首を斬るユーディット - Caravaggio (1598)
愛の勝利 - Caravaggio (1600s)
病めるバッカス - Caravaggio (1595)
ラス・メニーナス - Diego Velázquez (1656)
ブレダの開城 - Diego Velázquez (1635)
Saint Francis in Meditation - Francisco de Zurbarán (1639)
The Immaculate Conception - Francisco de Zurbarán (1661)
チャールズ1世の三面肖像画 - Anthony van Dyck (1635)
馬上のチャールズ1世とサン・アントワーヌの領主の肖像 - Anthony van Dyck (1636)
キリスト昇架 - Peter Paul Rubens (1609)
レウキッポスの娘たちの略奪 - Peter Paul Rubens (1618)
夜警 - Rembrandt van Rijn (1642)
自画像 - Rembrandt van Rijn (1659)
陽気な酒飲み - Frans Hals (1620s)
微笑む騎士 - Frans Hals (1624)