Perle de Modène

Raphaël · 1518

Perle de Modène - Raphaël

For years this small woman's head sat forgotten in a museum storeroom, inside a frame crowned with an eagle. Then a restorer looked beneath the paint and found a drawing that points to Raphael himself.

The story behind the painting

The Perla di Modena, the Pearl of Modena, is a small oil on panel, about 35 by 30 cm, now attributed to Raphael and kept in the Galleria Estense in Modena. Wikipedia dates it to 1518 to 1520, while Wikidata gives 1518. For a long time it stayed in the gallery's storerooms, in a very ornate frame topped by an eagle, the crest of the d'Este family. That frame caught the curiosity of the superintendent Mario Scalini, who sent the panel to the Florentine restorer Lisa Venerosi Pesciolini and to the laboratory Art-Test Firenze for study and scientific analysis.

What to look for

What is visible is a woman's head, with a halo behind it, painted on a small wooden panel. The restorer found a remarkable quality of painting, and beneath the surface an under-drawing, including a preparatory drawing that supports the idea that Raphael painted it himself. Look closely at the head: it is identical to the head of the Virgin in La Perla, the larger painting now in the Prado in Madrid. The halo is one of the clues used to make that link. The eagle on the original frame recalls other d'Este frames, some now on works in the Gemäldegalerie Alte Meister in Dresden.

Meaning and intent

The identification of the Modena panel rests on three pieces of evidence: the d'Este eagle on the frame, the mention of a woman's head by Raphael in a 1663 inventory of the d'Este collections, and the halo behind the head. The panel probably began as an initial version of La Perla and was abandoned because of flaws in the wood. That makes it a rare glimpse of a work in progress: a first attempt at a face that Raphael then carried into a finished altarpiece. Its interest lies less in a story than in what it reveals about how the painting was made.

Legacy

The panel also touches a long debate about La Perla itself. Once thought to be a late work by Raphael, La Perla came to be considered a work by Giulio Romano based on Raphael's drawings. In 2012, during the exhibition The Late Raphael at the Prado, the experts Paul Joannides and Tom Henry, together with specialists from the Prado and the Louvre, where the exhibition later travelled, concluded that the authorship should be restored to Raphael. The Modena head also shows how seventeenth-century painters in Emilia-Romagna looked to this face and to Raphael's Saint Cecilia as they developed their own classicism.

Le saviez-vous ?

Wikipedia · Wikidata

À propos de l'artiste

Raphaël (1483-1520)

femme · portrait · Haute Renaissance · cheveux longs · raie

Autres œuvres de Raphaël

Œuvres d'artistes liés