Hommes lisant

Francisco Goya · 1819

Hommes lisant - Francisco Goya

Six men press their heads together over a single printed page, lit from above in the dark. Goya painted them straight onto the wall of his own house, as one of the Black Paintings he never meant to show anyone.

The story behind the painting

Late in life, living alone outside Madrid in physical pain, spiritual torment and disillusionment with the political direction of Spain, Goya covered the walls of the Quinta del Sordo, the House of the Deaf Man, with fourteen bleak frescoes. Men Reading, also called The Reading or Politicians, is one of them. Wikipedia says it was likely completed between 1820 and 1823, while the museum date recorded on Wikidata is 1819. In 1873 and 1874 the murals were transferred to canvas under the supervision of Salvador Martinez Cubells, a curator at the Prado.

What to look for

Look at how tightly the six men are huddled, all eyes drawn to the page resting in the lap of the seated central figure. The light falls from the upper left, exactly as in its companion piece Women Laughing. Both pictures are vertical and smaller than the other Black Paintings, less dark in theme but darker in colour. X-rays show Goya changed a great deal: a landscape with a mounted rider once filled the background, and the central figure in white at one point had large horns, or perhaps bird wings, growing from his head.

Meaning and intent

No one knows for certain who these men are. They are often thought to be politicians reading and commenting on a newspaper article about themselves. Goya most likely placed the work on a smaller wall on the first floor of the house, beside Women Laughing and opposite The Dog and Two Old Men Eating Soup. The writer Francisco-Xavier de Salas Bosch linked the pair: the endless talk of the politicians was perhaps, in Goya's eyes, as sterile as the solitary act the laughing women mock in the companion picture.

Legacy

The owner of the murals, Baron Emile d'Erlanger, donated them to the Spanish state in 1881, and they are now shown at the Prado in Madrid. Studying the X-rays, the art historian Carmen Garrido found a large white lead impasto at the centre of the image, starting at the head of the man looking upwards. She noted that this area has neither the texture nor the usual structure of Goya's authentic brushstrokes, a finding that keeps scholars looking closely at how these private walls became museum pictures.

Le saviez-vous ?

Wikipedia · Wikidata

À propos de l'artiste

Francisco Goya (1746-1828)

scène de genre · musée du Prado

Autres œuvres de Francisco Goya

Œuvres d'artistes liés