The Just Judges

Jan van Eyck · 1432

The Just Judges - Jan van Eyck

Horsemen ride toward the Mystic Lamb, among them perhaps a duke and the painters themselves. One night in 1934 this panel was cut out of the Ghent Altarpiece, and it has never been seen again.

The story behind the painting

The Just Judges, also called The Righteous Judges, is the lower left panel of the Ghent Altarpiece, painted by Jan van Eyck or his brother Hubert between 1430 and 1432. It stood with the rest of the altarpiece in Saint Bavo Cathedral in Ghent until the night of 10 April 1934, when it was stolen, possibly by Arsene Goedertier. The thief removed it from the frame with apparent care, leaving the other panels unharmed, and left a note in French saying it had been taken from Germany by the Treaty of Versailles. That referred to the altarpiece having been taken to Berlin during the First World War and returned under Article 247 of the treaty.

What to look for

The panel is tall and narrow, 157.1 by 63.5 cm. It shows a group of mounted judges, and it is believed to include portraits of contemporaries such as Philip the Good, and possibly the artists Hubert and Jan van Eyck themselves. The original can no longer be seen. What hangs in Ghent today is a copy made by the Belgian restorer Jef Van der Veken, installed in 1945. He painted it on an old closet shelf about two centuries old and used as his model a mid sixteenth century copy by Michiel Coxie, made for Philip II of Spain. If you look closely at the horsemen in the copy, one has the face of King Leopold III.

Meaning and intent

The panel's meaning today is bound up with its absence. Within weeks the Bishop of Ghent received a ransom demand for one million Belgian francs, and the Belgian minister refused. Negotiations followed, with at least eleven letters through October, the government arguing that a national treasure belonged to the nation more than to the diocese. As a sign of good faith the thief returned one of the panel's two parts, a grisaille of Saint John the Baptist. On 25 November 1934 Goedertier told his lawyer on his deathbed that he alone knew where the panel was and would take the secret to his grave. The lawyer found copies of the ransom notes, and waited a month before telling the police.

Legacy

Many believe Goedertier could not have acted alone and suspect help from inside, perhaps from one of the cathedral's four custodians. Several people have claimed to know where the panel is, and searches have included an X-ray of the whole cathedral to a depth of ten metres. It has never been recovered and is now believed destroyed, yet to this day a Ghent police detective remains assigned to the case. Van der Veken added a layer of wax so his copy would match the patina of the other panels, and he signalled that it was a copy through Leopold III's face. Leopold was king both when the panel was stolen and when the copy was made.

Did you know?

Wikipedia · Wikidata

About the artist

Jan van Eyck (1390-1441)

religious art · Early Netherlandish painting · horse · city · judge

More by Jan van Eyck

Paintings by related artists