Édouard Manet · 1872

A tall man in a dark jacket, top hat and cane in one hand, head turned to his shoulder. Manet left only a sketch of his old friend. Someone else finished it, and even the signature was added after his death.
Manet knew Antonin Proust from school, and both then trained as painters in the studio of Thomas Couture. Proust soon gave up painting for journalism, became a deputy in 1876 and briefly minister of culture in 1881. Manet sketched him standing, full length, in his studio on the Rue d'Amsterdam. Wikipedia dates the work to around 1877, while Wikidata gives 1872. After Manet's death in 1883 the photographer Fernand Lochard recorded the sketch, and Suzanne Manet is said to have given it to Proust in 1884.
Lochard's photograph shows only the head and white collar worked up; the rest of the body is outlined in a few strokes, a top hat and cane in the left hand. Today the canvas, 182 by 110 cm, is fully detailed: a black jacket closed with one button, a pale beige waistcoat, a dark neckcloth, a light handkerchief in the breast pocket, light grey trousers. The left hand rests on a light brown cane and holds a glossy top hat. The width may have been cut by 15 cm, and the signature Manet, lower left, was added after his death.
When and by whom the sketch was reworked is unknown. In 2011 the curator Stéphane Guégan said experts agreed it belongs to sketches reworked for Manet's widow and her son Léon to make them easier to sell; since the widow had given it to Proust in 1884, a later reworking for someone else is also possible. Guégan still found charm and a certain elegance in it, recalling Henri Fantin-Latour's 1867 portrait of Manet. The pose with a hand on a stick holding a hat echoes Manet's 1876 portrait of Carolus-Duran.
Manet painted his friend again, and better known, in 1880: the portrait now in the Toledo Museum of Art, dedicated to my friend Antonin Proust and shown at the Paris Salon that year. The reworked canvas had a troubled history. It was acquired by the Wallraf-Richartz Museum in Cologne during the Second World War, returned to France after the war, and, with its ownership still unresolved, is shown today as a long term loan at the Musée Fabre in Montpellier.
Édouard Manet (1832-1883)
portrait · Wallraf-Richartz Museum · Musées Nationaux Récupération
Luncheon on the Grass - Édouard Manet (1863)
Olympia - Édouard Manet (1863)
Un bar ai Folies-Bergère - Édouard Manet (1882)
Il balcone - Édouard Manet (1868)
Music in the Tuileries - Édouard Manet (1862)
The Fif - Édouard Manet (1866)
The Railway - Édouard Manet (1873)
Nana - Édouard Manet (1877)
Impression, Sunrise - Claude Monet (1872)
Water Lilies - Claude Monet (1906)
Dance at Le Moulin de la Galette - Pierre-Auguste Renoir (1876)
Luncheon of the Boating Party - Pierre-Auguste Renoir (1881)
The Cradle - Berthe Morisot (1872)
Summer's Day - Berthe Morisot (1879)
L'Absinthe - Edgar Degas (1875)
The Bellelli Family - Edgar Degas (1858)
The Canal du Loing at Moret - Alfred Sisley (1892)
The Watering Pond at Marly with Hoarfrost - Alfred Sisley (1876)
Paris Street; Rainy Day - Gustave Caillebotte (1877)
Les raboteurs de parquet - Gustave Caillebotte (1875)