Raphael · 1500s

A young mother hands her baby a few carnations, small enough to hold like a prayer book. For a long time it was taken for a copy, and some still doubt it today.
La Madonna dei garofani, Madonna of the Carnation in Italian, is dated around 1505 to 1506 and usually attributed to Raphael. It is painted in oil on yew wood, a first for Raphael or any known Italian Renaissance painting. At only about 28 by 22 cm, little larger than a Book of Hours, it may have been a portable aid to prayer. The original patron is unknown. An inventory from the 1850s naming a nun called Maddalena degli Oddi is probably forged.
A youthful Virgin hands the child carnations. The room is grand, perhaps in a castle, opening to an alcove with a column and the tower of a small fort. The setting borrows from Leonardo's Benois Madonna, but here much of the grandeur is lost in darkness. The blue and green scheme linking the Virgin and the landscape is Raphael's own. Through the arched window is a mountaintop with a ruin, possibly the Fortezza Albornoz near Urbino.
The carnation, dianthus or flower of God, foretells the Passion: legend says it first appeared when the Virgin wept at the Crucifixion. The palette is limited: ultramarine and azurite for the sky and drapery, with lead tin yellow, malachite and verdigris. The attribution remains contested. James Beck argued it was by the Roman painter Vincenzo Camuccini, and Brian Sewell called it low quality, possibly forged, noting the Virgin's disconnected right leg.
In the nineteenth century it belonged to Vincenzo Camuccini. From 1853 it hung in Alnwick Castle, where scholars thought it merely the best of several copies of a lost original. In 1991 Nicholas Penny identified it as a genuine Raphael. In 2004 the National Gallery in London acquired it from the Duke of Northumberland after a major public appeal, and it then toured Manchester, Cardiff, Edinburgh and Barnard Castle. The debate about its author continues.
Raphael (1483-1520)
religious art · woman · Mary · Christ Child · High Renaissance · National Gallery · boy · mother
Sistine Madonna - Raphael (1510s)
La fornarina - Raphael
Madonna of the Goldfinch - Raphael (1500s)
The Marriage of the Virgin - Raphael (1504)
La velata - Raphael (1510s)
Three Graces - Raphael (1504)
Alba Madonna - Raphael (1510)
Madonna del Granduca - Raphael (1500s)
Venus of Urbino - Titian (1538)
Assumption of the Virgin - Titian (1510s)
Doni Tondo - Michelangelo (1500s)
The Torment of Saint Anthony - Michelangelo (1487)
Mona Lisa - Leonardo da Vinci (1503-1519)
Lady with an Ermine - Leonardo da Vinci (1490)
Self-Portrait with Fur-Trimmed Robe - Albrecht Dürer (1500)
Adoration of the Magi - Albrecht Dürer (1504)
The Birth of Venus - Sandro Botticelli (c. 1485)
Primavera - Sandro Botticelli (1480s)
The Garden of Earthly Delights - Hieronymus Bosch
Ship of Fools - Hieronymus Bosch (1500s)